
Never have I seen (call me unobservant) so much music journalism about what music journalism has said about an artist. Okay, that's a lie. Clearly everyone's favorite thing is not necessarily to read about an artist and his/her music, but rather to read about what other people think about that artist. Myself included. I would much rather read Noz's or Oliver Wang's or Sasha Frere Jones' much more developed, reasoned, researched, and contexualized comments, rather than stew over my own half-baked, knee-jerk reactions to a song or album. That said, the M.I.A. craze is crazed. Most of it I sift through but there has been some absolute brilliance in the mix. I'm far from blown away by M.I.A.'s music-- take that with a grain of salt. I love both Motley Crue and Fat Joe's "What's Love Got to Do With It" with a fierce passion that is anything but ironic-- and I feel similarly about the "political implications" of her ethnicity, multi-lingualness, or relation to a Tamil Tiger. The way I feel is, as B. Siegel and J. Smooth would say, everything is already real. So, I say, let's not overdo this. Making every single thing or nothing at all of M.I.A. isn't going to explain anything. Nor will it make her music more enjoyable to listen to.
Having lived in New York City and living on what I would like to believe is that cusp of hipsterness-- I know what hip is, I understand hipsterhood, I aspire to many of its aesthetics and ideals, but I will never truly be there, as I find much of it truly disgusting and masturbatory, (yet when I go to a bar am overwhelmingly attracted to the girls who are wearing white belts, old ass track shoes, and way too much indifference)-- I like to watch these things explode from afar. Call it M.I.A., call it Hollertronix, call it Mooney Suzuki, call it Dipset, call it grime, call it trucker hats. Either way. A fad is a fad is a fad is a fad.
Jon Caramanica's recent article in Slate says the most and least that has been said or needs to be said about M.I.A., better than anything else I have read on the topic. It seems to me that with music journalism it is challenging-- just how meta can you or your conversation get before your audience is annoyed and you've rendered your point of view stupid? This article is really good. To wit:
Away from the beats, however, M.I.A.'s politics begin to appear featherweight. She uses them in a way that feels calculated—a little bit of radical chic for the in-crowd. At the end of her set at the Knitting Factory, M.I.A. found a $20 bill on the floor of the stage. She picked it up, waved it at the audience, and said, "We're refugees. We can make 20 dollars go a long way." Although it was a delicious inversion of the familiar hip-hop practice of blithely throwing money into a crowd, it felt studied, more an idea of what the crowd might expect to hear than what she herself actually thought or felt. After de-arching her eyebrow, she closed her hand around the bill and quietly walked off stage.
---------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Poplicks is killing it.
2. Blogger, I fucking hate you. If my other free blog host wasn't a stalker who went bananas, I would so totally leave you.